T O P
First_Among_Equals_

The one prospect not on this that I really want to highlight is Zamir White...he didn't grade highly for me...but I have him as a sleeper to be a solid NFL RB if he can stay healthy


Brush-Okie

Is "round" the same as tier?


First_Among_Equals_

Yeah pretty much. The right hand columns would be tiers


Maxx0utt

This is great! Would love to see a wr comparison


First_Among_Equals_

Yeah I’ll post it. This one just felt long after I finished the RBs


JPMoney81

Looking forward to that one. Great work so far, thanks for sharing.


FF_Mikey10

It’s always nice to see some Etienne love… sad about Spiller though. What were your knocks on him?


First_Among_Equals_

Spiller had a bad combine which is weighed into my grading. On tape, I see a guy who is solid all around but doesn’t appear special athletically and will limit his ceiling. He doesn’t particularly run with much power either. He definitely can carve out a role for himself in the league and be a decent player but I struggle to see him ever being an elite asset. If he comes out at his pro day though and can make his combine look like a fluke then he could receive a decent bump to RB3


tankfortua20

BDGE youtube channel has a guy who broke down Spiller as a prospect. Kinda kills Spiller as from an analytical perspective. Also brings a ton of analytical data for the rest of the rbs.


Caloran

Way to reactionary there man his body of work alone should have him in at least one tier higher. Putting that much stock into one combine is a little crazy when hes been a 5 star recruit since high school and was productive in college.


First_Among_Equals_

I wasn’t high on him regardless of the combine. If anything I’m still propping him up in my rankings despite the combine


FF_Mikey10

Ahh gotcha, appreciate the response!


psuedodoc

The reporting on Spiller is that he was injured and wasn’t healthy for the combine. If he performs poorly at his pro day, then I see your point. Using his combine scoring seems silly, I’d say just redact it for now and wait for the pro day.


First_Among_Equals_

I have factored in the combine but I’ve also given him a huge benefit of the doubt already that’s propping him up. Solid chances that he falls lower if pro day testing isn’t good


psuedodoc

Solid chance huh? We shall see… I’m not saying he’s JT. But he’s talented. He’s exactly what NFL rosters want.


SDG1994

Why so low on Rachaad White? I know he’s not considered a top prospect but I like him as a 2-3 round sleeper


First_Among_Equals_

I don’t think he plays up to his combine testing. His acceleration doesn’t look as fast on film as his testing would indicate. Don’t necessarily trust his pacing as a runner. I think he tries too hard sometimes to make something happen and make a guy miss, which is great for highlights when it works but not always best IRL. Who knows I could be wrong about him though!


watevergoes

Where's Jonathan Taylor?


First_Among_Equals_

Number 1…


watevergoes

Whoopsies.


Contren

I did the same thing, the bolded name made me skip him thinking it was a category title and not a player.


Fragmented_Logik

I'd swap Dobbins and Hall but overall pretty solid list. (My reason being Hall did ALOT more with ALOT less) Next genstats also have Hall in the 99th percentile and labeled elite compared to Dobbins they had at 89th and Good. His combine was solid and one thing over looked is the age factor. A lot of these guys combine day were how old? Breece Hall is still 20 for a couple more months lol.


[deleted]

[удалено]


roxasaur

https://twitter.com/SmartfootbalI/status/1477177731032883200 https://twitter.com/SmartfootbalI/status/1483371684920918022


mfancy

So you’re saying you’d take Dobbins over Walker? I’m debating about moving 1.3 for Dobbins. Hall and one of the WRs will be gone before I make my pick. I’m deep at WR so was looking to add some RB depth, just wasn’t sure if that was the right move.


First_Among_Equals_

As a prospect I preferred dobbins… Now it’s hard to tell until post draft and FA. Who knows if dobbins will be in a timeshare or if Walker gets a good landing spot etc. Id probably hold Walker over dobbins just due to the reset on the rookie contract but that’s me


KingBaba3

I prefer dobbins over all rbs but breece this draft. And that’s still considering where breece goes.


tankfortua20

I think this is more of his prospect rankings.


iia

Surprised to see you so high on CEH, considering how he's fallen so far out of favor around here. I don't disagree, though.


SquidwardTestic1es

These are prospect ratings. So nothing to do with how they’ve shown so far.


iia

Gotcha.


roxasaur

I really don't understand the James Cook hype outside of the connection to Dalvin. I'd be curious what your model thought about Tyler Allgeier, Tyler Badie, Kevin Harris, or Jashaun Corbin.


First_Among_Equals_

They’re all lower than white. And cook isn’t exactly “hyped” for me. He’s my RB3 in the class but the context the previous years provides shows I don’t exactly think he’s anything special


ManagementOk6440

Thanks for sharing, always love to see how prospects from different classes stack up


[deleted]

[удалено]


First_Among_Equals_

I mean this isn’t necessarily a “model”. It’s my grades and how I saw them as prospects with some model like stuff used to help


Shmeklenburg

i took over an orphan team in ppr and traded dobbins for david montgomery... thoughts..?


chawlini

I’d rather have Dobbins


Shmeklenburg

Full ppr..? I'm a ravens fan (born in baltimore) and they don't really pass to their backs. If Montgomery would have played whole season may have been top five back. Def top ten


chawlini

I think Dobbins is the more talented running back. Bears might’ve utilized DM better for fantasy production in 2020-2021. But I think Dobbins will have the better career.


Shmeklenburg

I don't disagree with being better back but full point ppr and lamar redzone usage... scares me just a bit. We will see how it plays out. Ravens also got some o line voids to fill


Leading-Tennis

Michael carter ?


First_Among_Equals_

Was my RB8 behind the 6 listed and Hubbard


Leading-Tennis

I'd imagine khalil herbert after that . I got both lol


First_Among_Equals_

Kylin Hill then Herbert


lib_a_

Why would Elijah Mitchell be ahead of Sermon as a prospect? Sermon was drafted 3 rounds sooner.